Long Spined Sea Urchin Strategy

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Tackling the long spined sea urchin

The incursion of the long spined sea urchin Centrostephanus rodgersii into Tasmanian waters over the past 40 years represents a significant range extension for this species.  Unchecked, the urchin’s presence represents a risk to the ecological balance of the important​ Tasmanian rocky reef ecosystem on the East Coast.

 
Video courtesy of Institute for Marine and Antarctic Studies

Eradication is simply not achievable with the tools currently available and there is no silver bullet to fix the problem, so a multi-pronged approach to mitigate the urchin’s impact is the most effective option. 
 

How did it get here?

The long spined urchin has undergone range extension southwards from its native habitat in New South Wales waters over the past 40 years.  It has been able to thrive in Tasmanian waters more recently  due to the warming waters off the East Coast largely associated with changes to the East Australian Current.

Why is it a problem?

Fisheries that rely on healthy rocky reef habitat are very important to the Tasmanian community from an economic and social perspective.  The community has an expectation of pristine, balanced reef systems however, once established on a reef, the long spined urchins graze on kelp and other marine plants, forming bare patches called 'incipient' or emerging barrens. If left to its own devices,  urchin numbers will continue to increase and the level of overgrazing on kelp is likely to completely denude the reef of all seaweed, forming an 'extensive' or established barren.

These extensive barrens significantly impact on the biodiversity of rocky reef habitat with devastating impact on recreational and commercial fisheries particularly abalone, rock lobster and some scalefish species robbing these fisheries of feed and habitat.   Once established, the extensive barrens can be maintained and can continue to expand by just a few urchins.  The point where incipient (patchy) barrens become extensive (bare bottom) barrens is referred to the tipping point which is pivotal to the management approach adopted.   The full-blown extensive barren, requires the removal of all the urchins from the site to be cleared over an extended period before we can turn back the clock and allow the algal habitat and fisheries to recover.

Long spined sea urchin barren
 
Large rock lobsters are one of the few natural predators of the long spined urchin.  However, lobster stocks have declined on the East Coast due to periods of low recruitment and fishing activity.

A combination of climate change and depleted lobster stocks are important factors contributing to the expansion of long spined urchin barrens.

What is known about urchin barrens?

A recent report by the Institute of Marine and Antarctic Studies (IMAS) on long spine sea urchins on reefs along Tasmania's East Coast (the IMAS long term study) has measured increases in the urchin population and the barren areas they create by overgrazing kelp beds.
 
Urchin barrens can extend over hectares of the seabed and in depths up to 60 plus metres.  But peak barren formation occurs in a depth range of 20 - 30m.
 
There are some baseline data of the abundance and distribution of long spined sea urchin barrens resulting from the, systematic surveys conducted by IMAS in 2001/02 which were re-surveyed in 2008/09 and then again in 2016/2017 by IMAS divers and underwater towed video to monitor changes and trends in the abundance and extent of the impact of the long spined urchins over time.

Is the problem getting worse?

The latest IMAS survey estimates that the biomass of long spined urchins in 0 - 18m depth is around 3,276 tonnes with major barren formations in the vicinity of St Helens, Freycinet, Schouten Island and Maria Island.  

Smaller barrens are currently forming in the Eddystone Point, Four Mile Creek, Bicheno and the Tasman Peninsula regions.  

Data from a towed video survey in 18 - 30m depth range suggest a similar biomass level to inshore or a total long spined urchin biomass of around 6500 tonnes.

What management action is being taken?

Although total eradication of the long spined urchin is not considered possible, a lack of active intervention is predicted  to result in a steady  increase in urchin barrens.  The latest IMAS report does suggest possible actions and it is encouraging to note that continued proactive management of urchin overgrazing, such as rebuilding urchin predators and upscaling of culling and/ or harvesting activities appear to be plausible means of control’.​

One of the key components in the battle against the northern invader is the recent allocation of $5.1 M over 5 years allocated by the Tasmanian State Government to support and increase the sustainability and productivity of the Tasmanian abalone fishery.

The funds are administered by the Abalone Industry Reinvestment Fund Committee (AIRF), which operates on a co-management approach between the abalone industry, the Department and IMAS.

The additional funding has allowed a multi-pronged approach to be put in place to tackle the long spined sea urchin with a range of future options also being considered. Current and past research data is available to underpin any future management actions that will be undertaken and this information base is expanding rapidly.

One of the key developments the AIRF has progressed, is the development of an overarching State strategy to guide the control efforts for the long spined urchin to help ensure that consistent aims and objectives are maintained.   The State strategy is being led by a team from the CSIRO who developed the response strategy to tackle the crown of thorns sea star threat to the Great Barrier Reef.

Main Objectives of the Strategy
Reducing the ongoing risk of the destruction of healthy kelp beds and then rehabilitating established urchin barrens to a balanced habitat are fundamentally two different problems requiring different solutions.

The multi pronged sea urchin strategy has three key objectives:
  • Stop growth of existing barrens
  • Prevent establishment of new barrens
  • ​Promote recovery of full barrens

Strategies to achieve the objectives

The severity of the threat posed by long spined sea urchins to Tasmania's rocky reef ecosystems and consequently to the fisheries, tourism operations and local communities who depend on the natural balance being maintained requires the urchin to be tackled with an array of weapons. 

Possible means include:

  • a biological approach such as the re-building and translocation of rock lobster stocks;  
  • market based strategies such as subsidies and the development of new domestic and overseas markets; and
  • a physical approach which includes divers smashing and harvesting the pest. 

All these strategies are currently being employed and are having an impact. There are also a number of research projects which are showing promise for future control options. 

The use of experimental techniques such as robots and liming is also being assessed as part of the AIRF.  Overseas cases have shown builders lime has a devastating effect on the urchins when only a few grains are applied to the test (shell inside the spins).  However, there will need to be extensive testing under local conditions before any Tasmanian ecosystems are exposed to the treatment - a pilot, laboratory project is now underway to assess the feasibility of using lime in Tasmanian waters.

The urchins are also being assessed for their effectiveness as a fertiliser through a collaborative approach between industry and IMAS while a project to evaluate the most efficient use of subsidies has just been completed.  These varied applications all make taking the urchins a more attractive proposition for divers and processors alike.

Below is a brief description of some of the more prominent tools currently being used to control the incursion.

Commercial harvesting

On extensive barrens, kelp will only be restored by 'direct human intervention' using techniques such as harvesting (removal) and culling to control urchin numbers. Predators such as large lobsters are unlikely to be able reduce urchin numbers to the point where the seaweed can re-establish itself in the near term given the scale of many existing barrens. On incipient (patchy) barrens, commercial harvesting and culling, and lobster predation may all have a role to play. Of all these techniques, the one that is currently most advanced is urchin harvesting.

It was initially thought there were no markets for long spined sea urchin roe as the roe was considered bitter and unpalatable. Market interest in the product has now increased following development of better processing techniques which has , in turn, resulted in very successful market development.

The tonnage of longspined urchins harvested had been gradually increasing from 2008 to 2014 when the harvest reached 97 tonnes.  Interest waned in 2015 and 2016 as processing facilities showed little interest in progressing the development of the longspined fishery.  However, in 2016, the abalone industry introduced a subsidy to be paid to the commercial dive sector as a means of enticing fish processors into harvesting the urchins for the roe. 

The subsidy was a resounding success, with one processor in particular investing heavily in the product and being rewarded by the expansion of demand for the product exceeding expectations.

The subsidy is now funded by the AIRF and over the last year over 555 tonnes of urchins have been removed from Tasmanian State waters primarily for the sale of their roe (gonads).  That equates to roughly 1,665,000 longspined urchins which will now no longer destroy valuable abalone, rock lobster and scalefish habitat.  A graph of the development of the Centrostephanus harvest is shown below and the impact of the subsidy in 2017, 2018 and 2019 can be clearly identified.  It should be noted that the IMAS surveys indicate that the longspined urchin biomass off Tasmania, has been increasing by some 180 tonnes annually.  Over the last 12 months, the commercial fishery has effectively removed biomass equivalent to three years of new urchin recruitment.
Tonnage of long spined sea urchins taken by commercial divers by fishing year

All reports suggest that the areas that were harvested are already showing significant signs of improvement but a project funded by the AIRF will soon be undertaken to quantify the effects of commercial fishing on the Centrostephanus numbers and the recovery of barrens.

Ongoing commercial harvesting, complemented by targeted culling, are likely to be important ongoing activities to reduce urchin numbers.  The need for a continued subsidy of both activities is an issue that requires annual review.  A detailed independent assessment of the efficacy of the harvesting subsidy was supported by the AIRF in mid-2019.  A copy of that report is available on the IMAS website.

Read more about Tasmania's commercial sea urchin fishery.

 

Centrostephanus being processed to extract the roe

Centrostephanus roe as the final product

Culling by smashing

Commercial divers and abalone divers have culled long ​spined urchins as part of research projects over the last 10 years.  This is another ‘direct human intervention’ tool that can help protect small specific patches of reef from turning into extensive barrens.

Sea urchin diverCulling of long spined urchins can be undertaken by commercial divers

In terms of other forms of physical intervention, trials have shown that urchins can be culled from discrete areas and that regrowth of kelp may occur in that area.  These removals are more successful if at least two episodes of removal are conducted – and may require further ongoing efforts for long term removal.

However, such programs would seem practical in only small or key areas due to the resource intensive effort required.  In the near future, culling will only be undertaken for experimental purposes (to learn more about efficacy) or in areas where there is an immediate threat to habitat which cannot be quickly addressed by harvesting.  The utility of developing a management framework for recreational dive groups to undertake similar 'protect a patch' activities may be considered in the future, as part of the overall Centrostephanus Response Strategy.

What role can large lobsters play?

Large lobsters at sufficient density are able to limit urchin populations effectively in healthy kelp beds to ​help minimize risk of barrens formation.  Large lobsters are also able to limit urchin populations on incipient barrens, facilitating recovery of seaweeds and minimizing risk of further expansion of barrens.

While large lobsters do prey on urchins, increasing rock lobster biomass alone will not result in the recovery of extensive urchin barrens, as they are unable to reduce urchin numbers to the point where kelp and other seaweed can re-establish.  Even if extensive barrens are closed to lobster fishing indefinitely and populations of large lobsters on barrens are boosted by transplanting at realistically achievable levels, the likelihood of recovery of kelp is negligible in the absence of any other mechanism to reduce urchin density.  On extensive barrens, kelp will only be restored by additional intervention, for example by removing urchins using divers, quicklime, or robots.

Once urchins are at sufficiently low densities to allow reef habitat to recover, maintaining populations of large lobsters in regenerated kelp beds is likely to be sufficient to prevent return to urchin barrens.

Rock Lobster Translocation Program

The stock rebuilding strategy is supported by the East Coast Translocation Program undertaken as part of the East Coast Stock Rebuilding Strategy.  Under this program, undersize lobsters from slow-growing deep-water areas in the South West are translocated to inshore east coast locations including known incipient barren areas.  

Read more about the Rock Lobster Translocation Program.

Further action and funding

DPIPWE convenes an annual Centro Forum towards the end of each calendar year to share progress and seek input from key stakeholder organisations.  The second Forum was held in November 2019 and was highlighted by a series of sector-based roundtables to refine inputs to the Centrostephanus Response Strategy being developed by CSIRO. 

Centro Forum 22 Nov 2019

Report and presentations from the two forums held to date are available below:

Centrostephanus Forum #1 December 2018

Main Report:
2018 Centrostephanus Forum Report

Presentations:
2017/18 Centrostephanus Survey Results - Scott Ling (IMAS)
Rock Lobster Harvest Strategy - Klaas Hartmann (IMAS)
Harvest subsidy program update - Dean Lisson (Tas Abalone Council)
Centrostephanus harvesting progress to date - John Keane (IMAS)
Culling Trial results - Craig Mundy (IMAS)
Assessment models for planning effective control of Centrostephanus - Katie Cresswell (IMAS)
Lessons from Crown of Thorns Starfish control programs - Ian Dutton (DPIPWE)
Norwegian experience with urchin control - Hans Strand (IMR Norway)

Centrostephanus Forum #2 November 2019

Main Report:

2019 Centrostephanus Forum Report

Presentations:

Research and monitoring by IMAS

The IMAS report summarises some of the actions already in place and some possible future approaches to upscale mitigation, including:
  • ongoing commercial fishery, potential of further subsidy;
  • culling by abalone divers while they fish;
  • systematic paid targeted culling;
  • rebuilding of lobster stocks;
  • translocation of rock lobsters to the east coast;
  • diver-harvest of urchins from barrens for marine farming - caged feeding to improve roe quality to the point that they’re suitable for sale;
  • recovery of extensive barrens via piping quicklime to the reef surface;
  • automated culling of urchins using robotic technology.
To assess the effectiveness of current and novel mitigation methods, future surveys of urchin density and barren coverage would be required. The effectiveness of fishing/ mitigation measures may also benefit from fine-scale spatial mapping of effort via GPS and depth loggers and/ or mobile web-applications.

 

Contact

Wild Fisheries Management Branch
1 Franklin Wharf
GPO Box 44
Hobart TAS 7001
Phone: 03 6165 3000, 1300 368 550
Email: fishing.enquiries@dpipwe.tas.gov.au

Back Home